Does Wing Chun Work In A Street Fight?

A commonly asked question from budding martial artists is ‘Does Wing Chun work?’ Most people have at least some knowledge of Wing Chun from the various Ip Man movies which have popularised the art. Perhaps slightly lesser known is that Wing Chun was the first martial art that Bruce Lee practiced. This was before he switched over to a variety of styles which he called Jeet Kun Do, more commonly thought of as mixed martial arts in the present day.

All martial arts are designed to build you both physically and mentally, Wing Chun is no different from this. If we think about Wing Chun in relation to other martial arts such as Muay Thai or Western Boxing, it is not as competitive and difficult to find an actual tournament or big money fight. However, its roots are still similar since it is essentially a striking and blocking martial art.

All martial arts are meant to teach you self-defense and how to protect yourself in a street fight. Wing Chun can often be seen being taught with a wooden dummy, this allows the student to practice their various blocks and strikes. Whilst it is no substitute for sparring and pressure testing, it will cause your form to improve over time.

Wing Chun uses dirtier moves compared to other styles

The difference between Wing Chun and the aforementioned martial arts is that Wing Chun is a close-quarters combat fighting system. The distance between you and your opponent is a lot smaller than a boxing match for example. This is why blocking strikes with your hands, arms, and elbows are always emphasized. Most modern-day martial arts are not taught with weapons, however, sometimes Wing Chun is practiced in this way.

Although in general if you add a weapon to any striking martial art, there is always some practicality where the technique will not need much modification. For this reason, Wing Chun is not a silver bullet defense in a street fight if you are attacked with a weapon, but it may give you more of an advantage if we compare it to another martial art.

A good example of when Wing Chun works is through some of its dirty moves. Wing Chun taught the likes of eye pokes, gouges, and kicks to the knee. These are all illegal in fighting promotions but can be very effective in street fights. Of course, you must be careful that you do not kill or seriously injure the opponent whilst doing these techniques.

What Would Happen If You Were Attacked On The Street?

Wing Chun would be a good counter to any 1 on 1 street fight attacker. This is because it relies on blocking and striking your opponent. If you are able to block and parry their strikes, they will not be able to harm you as easily. Another fundamental idea of Wing Chun is that you’re able to block your opponent’s strikes in such a way that it affects and hurts their balance. Due to this, you are now in a much better position to counter with a strike of your own since they have no defense.

If the opponent is carrying a weapon such as a stick or a knife and you can’t run away, Wing Chun is not going to save your life 100% of the time, but at least would improve your odds of dodging the fatal blow. This is because Wing Chun is designed and sometimes trained to combat weapons. The system recognizes that people will not always attack you fairly, so you are already prepared if this scenario happens. Of course, fighting against weapons is never fair, and so it’s unfair to criticize Wing Chun if you’re attacked with weapons.

The Flaws Of Wing Chun In A Street Fight

Whilst it is a practical martial art to keep yourself safe, Wing Chun is not a solution to stop an attacker (then again, neither is any martial art). If you were in a 1 vs 2 or a 1 vs 3 scenario, your odds of survival are significantly reduced. This is due to the fact that your body and mind are simply not fast enough to deal with 2 or more people. It may only take one blow to the head to rock you, if you are knocked to the floor then no matter how good your Wing Chun abilities are, they will be useless.

Continuing on from the last point, Wing Chun may be less effective against a wrestler, judoka, or BJJ expert. This is because it does not have any ground training techniques. If you were to get put onto the floor by any of these takedown specialists, they could essentially pin you there and strike you. This is the main limitation of Wing Chun as an overall martial art, it is very good at blocking, parrying, and countering strikes, but there is no takedown defense.

Because of this, if you find yourself against a takedown specialist, you may be in trouble. Still, at least you’d have some kind of offense, compared to being untrained. This is where the dirtier moves could also play a role, depending on the scenario.

Wing Chun struggles against hook punches

As well as takedowns, another noticeable flaw of Wing Chun is its weakness against hooks being thrown. Typically, a lot of Wing Chun involves blocking and diverting strikes down the middle. So, against straight jabs it may well work. Against teep kicks, it may also be fine. However, against hooks and roundhouse kicks that come from the outside, it doesn’t offer many solutions.

Because of this, you could argue that Wing Chun also struggles against fighters who are happy to keep a distance and throw strikes at range, as opposed to strikes from close. Arguably, if you’re worried about this as a Wing Chun practitioner then you could always train something like Taekwondo which may deal with fighting at a distance more that Wing Chun does.

Proof of Wing Chun working in street fights

Perhaps one of the biggest complements of Wing Chun was its successful application in street fights. Apparently, Ip Man had many fights over the years and would even teach local thugs how to fight better in his dojo. Although this business practice may be questionable, it still speaks volumes about the success of Wing Chun when applied against street brawlers.

Of course, history often over-exaggerates things, and the myth of Ip Man may be overcooked. Still, it is a fact that he did use Wing Chun whilst fighting and taught it to local fighters. This alone points towards Wing Chun being good in a combat setting. Arguably though, we always knew this and Wing Chun at its purest has never been questioned. Instead, it’s the possible watered-down version that has less of a reliable reputation.

What Really Matters Most

The most important factor when training Wing Chun for real self-defense and street fight scenarios is how it is trained. If you are simply training in the dojo to block and counter pre-determined and drilled attacks, then this is what you will become an expert at. However, if you are sparring each other properly by trying a variety of strikes to the head and chest of your opponents then you will get hit a lot more and start to learn from your mistakes.

Once you have sparred like this enough times, your brain will begin to learn how to dodge attacks more effectively and how to counter certain strikes. This is an invaluable experience that you would not have learned without sparring, thus giving you an edge over people who do not practice martial arts in this way.

Because your Wing Chun abilities have been “pressure tested”, you will now be able to be more confident in your own skills and know what your own limits are. Perhaps you are able to beat an amateur-level boxer in a fight, or maybe you’re not ready for this. By sparring other people you will at least find out what your skill level is, rather than being completely in the dark and guessing that you’re better than you actually are.

Another point is whether who is teaching you the martial art is actually qualified to do so. A certificate is not enough. If your teacher cannot beat you in sparring Wing Chun, then perhaps it is you who should be teaching them! Seriously though, if you can beat your teacher then this can sometimes be a positive thing. This shows that ‘the apprentice becomes the master’ so to speak, which shows you have been taught correctly enough to go further than your original teacher.

Summary

Overall the answer is yes, Wing Chun can help you win a street fight and will help your self-defense. Whilst it may not be the best martial art in the world either, it’s still solid nonetheless. What is worth noting about Wing Chun is that it offers unusual techniques compared to other martial arts. Basically, it’s pretty unique and can pose unorthodox threats to budding attackers who aren’t used to its unusual style.

Just like anything in life, it must be trained and sparred properly for it to be effective. And, this is where the big dilemma lies with Wing Chun – in finding a legitimate dojo to learn real fighting techniques that can be used on the streets. Otherwise, it may be fun to learn, but it is not going to help you when you need to rely on it. With this said, a fun martial art may be entertaining, but ultimately most people train for survival which is the main point of combat training.

If you’re a fan of Wing Chun then check out this brilliant technique book here.